Classic Patty Melt

Crispy, butter-soaked bread wraps around a sizzling beef patty and gooey cheese in this beloved diner staple that sits right between a burger and grilled cheese sandwich. Every mouthful delivers the ideal mix of meaty flavor, melty cheese, and crunchy toast, making a heartwarming meal that hits the spot without needing burger buns or outdoor grilling equipment.

I fell in love with patty melts during a road trip across America, and I couldn't stop trying to make that perfect mix of crisp outside and juicy inside at home. This version came after tons of kitchen tests and has become what my family asks for when we want something filling on busy nights without dealing with the grill.

Key Components

• Ground Beef: Go for 80/20 beef to get the right balance between taste and juiciness.
• Bread: Chunky rye bread makes a great strong foundation plus adds that nice caraway seed flavor.
• Cheese: Mix sharp cheddar with provolone for the best melt and taste combo.
• Special Sauce: Mixing mayo, ketchup, sweet relish, and bits of bacon creates an amazing tangy-sweet topping.
• Butter: Use genuine butter to get that trademark golden crunch that makes eating this sandwich so good.

Making Fantastic Patty Melts

Beef Prep:

Start by mixing salt, pepper, and onion powder into your ground beef, stirring lightly to spread the seasonings without squeezing the meat too much. Shape into flat patties a bit wider than your bread since they'll shrink while cooking.

Cooking Method:

Sear the patties in a hot pan until you get a nice dark crust, then lower the heat to finish cooking them through. This two-step method gives you tasty browned outsides while keeping the inside moist.

Making The Sauce:

Stir mayo and ketchup together until they're fully blended, then mix in bacon pieces and sweet relish. This mix gives you rich flavors that work great with the beef and cheese without being too strong.

Putting It Together:

Put cheese right against the bread on top and bottom, with the meat in between. This way, the cheese melts into both the bread and patty, sticking everything together perfectly.

Perfect Toasting:

Cook your sandwich over medium-low heat, pressing down gently to make sure everything touches. Don't rush it - let each side get golden brown before you flip it, which creates that signature crunch in a great patty melt.

Pin it

My grandma always put a thin coat of mustard right on the bread before toasting her patty melts. She said it kept the bread from getting soggy and added a nice tangy flavor. Some traditionalists might not agree, but I've never wanted to question her methods when the results taste so good.

Great Side Dishes

Enjoy these hearty sandwiches with some crunchy dill pickles to balance out the richness. For the full diner feeling, add some super thin crispy fries or a simple vinegar-dressed coleslaw that cuts through the sandwich's heaviness.

Tasty Twists

Switch things up by using sourdough bread and throwing in some caramelized onions for a sweet and savory combo. Make a morning version with a thinner patty, an egg, and some maple-flavored bacon. For some southwestern flair, toss in green chilies and use pepper jack cheese.

Keeping It Fresh

Though these sandwiches taste best right off the stove, you can make the patties and sauce ahead of time. Keep cooked patties in your fridge for up to two days, then put together and toast your sandwiches when you're ready to eat.

Through many years of making patty melts, I've found this simple sandwich is loved by practically everyone - burger fans and grilled cheese lovers alike. There's something special about how the butter-crisped bread, juicy beef, and melted cheese work together, creating a meal that feels like more than just the parts that went into it.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How is a patty melt different from a burger?

It’s always built on rye bread, has melted cheese like cheddar or Swiss, and is grilled flat like a crunchy sandwich.

→ Can I add onions to my melt?

Of course! Sauté onions slowly for about 15-20 minutes until they turn golden and sweet for a traditional touch.

→ What’s the top cheese option?

Swiss is classic, but cheddar and provolone melt beautifully. American cheese is another good pick.

→ Can I swap beef for a leaner option?

Yes, you can use chicken or turkey. Just add a little oil to keep the meat juicy and prevent sticking.

→ What sides complement patty melts?

Some great pairings are fries, onion rings, chips, pickles, or a fresh salad.