Pin
I crave these jam-packed baked potatoes whenever I've had a rough one. They’ve got mouthwatering bits of steak, light and airy potato insides, and a rich, dreamy parmesan sauce. Honestly, it feels like restaurant magic but you can whip it up in your own kitchen. Want to wow your family at a small get-together or just spoil yourself when it’s cold? This one totally hits the spot.
I gave this a shot when I had some steak left after dinner. Stuffed it into baked potatoes and my family wouldn’t quit raving. Now it’s our go-to when we want something that fills you up!
Mouthwatering Ingredients
- Red pepper flakes: Sprinkles in gentle spice. You get to pick how hot you like it.
- Fresh parsley: Chopped on top for a little green and some zip go with flat leaf if you can.
- Lemon: Freshly squeezed juice adds zing and brightens up the rich sauce.
- Parmesan, grated: Get a block and grate it yourself for max cheesy goodness.
- Heavy cream: This is what helps the sauce go super smooth don’t use the kinds with weird stuff added in.
- Avocado oil: Doesn’t burn easy and makes steak brown up really well, stick with cold pressed if you see it.
- Cajun seasonings: Bring bold flavors—watch the salt if your mix is salty or try something smoky.
- Butter: Bring it to room temp so it’s simple to spread and use a good unsalted kind for richness.
- Garlic: Chop up fresh garlic so every bite pops use solid heavy cloves.
- Kosher salt: Makes both the steak and potato taste better all over.
- Steak: Go with NY strip, ribeye, sirloin, or tenderloin—whatever’s around and marbled for juiciness.
- Sea salt: Makes crunchy, salty skins on your taters use big flaky sea salt for oomph.
- Olive oil: Get those potato skins nice and crackly use pure olive oil if you can.
- Large russet potatoes: You want them firm with smooth skins so you get mega crisp outsides and fluffy inside.
- Freshly cracked pepper: Just-ground pepper gives a sharp, fresh finish at the end.
Easy How-To Steps
- Plating Everything:
- When the potatoes have finished roasting go ahead and drop them on the pan once from up high to loosen the fluffy insides. Split them down the middle and use a fork to fluff. Slide a chunk of leftover butter inside. Load in all those steak pieces, then pour a decent amount of parmesan sauce over the whole top. Sprinkle parsley before digging in—these are best hot so don’t wait.
- Cheesy Cream Sauce:
- Stick with the same pan your steak cooked in—makes the sauce even more flavorful. Swirl in the last of your butter with any garlic left over. When you smell the garlic start to cook, pour in the heavy cream slowly while whisking. Let it almost boil then let it reduce and thicken for three to five minutes. Toss in parmesan and some pepper flakes, stirring till it’s shiny and thicker. Add a little kosher salt plus cracked pepper if needed. Kill the heat, stir in parsley, and squirt in lemon juice to jazz it up.
- Steak Prep:
- While your potatoes are roasting, trim away any tough bits from your steak and chop it into chunky two-inch cubes. Glug half the avocado oil over top and toss with lots of cajun spice. Heat up a cast iron skillet with the rest of the oil. Once it’s super hot, arrange the steak so none are touching—don’t crowd the pan. Brown them for two minutes, flip, then another minute. Lower the heat and give it just another minute; you want it pink inside.
- Garlic Butter Finish:
- Push the steak to one side of your pan. Pop in two spoonfuls butter and half the garlic on the empty side. Wait just till it smells amazing (about thirty seconds), then toss steak bites around so they get coated in all that garlicky goodness. This keeps ’em juicy and full of taste. Pile them into a bowl and cover with foil to keep them moist.
- Roasting Potatoes:
- Get your oven set to 425 and throw some parchment on a baking sheet. Roll potatoes with olive oil so they’re shiny, then douse them with sea salt all over. Put on the pan and roast for forty-five to sixty minutes, or till they’re soft—stick a fork in to check. Forget poking holes; letting them steam makes fluffy potato centers.
Pin
The way the cheesy sauce melts into the hot steak and potato always takes me back. Growing up, these were Sunday favorites—everyone laughed and tried to swipe the cheesiest bite off each other’s plate.
Leftover Storage
Keep leftover stuffed potatoes in the fridge for as much as three days. Wrap each potato in foil, or stash in something airtight. It’s best to reheat them in the oven at 350, uncovered, till totally hot but the steak stays juicy. Microwave whole potatoes only if you have to—they can end up dry and tough.
Swap Options
If you like to keep things lighter, use cooked chicken instead of steak or work with leftovers. Yukon Golds also make a great stand-in if you’re out of russets. If you need a sauce change, swap heavy cream for half and half (your sauce will just be a bit thinner). Try asiago instead of parmesan for a new spin.
How to Serve
Pair these loaded potatoes with a crunchy green salad or a side of steamed broccoli to freshen things up. Garlic bread never hurts if you want to make it a feast. Give extra zing by topping with chopped chives or a spoon of sour cream for tang.
Tasty Backstory
This dish is a staple at American steakhouses and comfort-food spots. Steak, fluffy potato, and creamy sauce together just screams cozy and filling. Folks have been turning simple foods into something huge and satisfying like this for ages.
Recipe Questions & Answers
- → Which steak option is best for these potatoes?
Try sirloin, ribeye, tenderloin, or NY strip—they all brown up nicely and stay tender. Pick whatever you like or fits your wallet.
- → What’s the secret to potatoes that are fluffy inside?
Blast your potatoes in a hot oven and drop each one gently on the counter before you slice them open. It really loosens up those insides.
- → Can I make the steak bites ahead?
Definitely. Sear your steak pieces, stash them in the fridge, and when ready, warm 'em gently in the skillet before loading up your potatoes.
- → Do I have to use a cast iron pan?
Cast iron gives you that perfect steak sear, but any sturdy skillet with a thick bottom will do the job just fine for steak bites.
- → What perks up the parmesan sauce?
Fresh lemon, red pepper flakes, garlic, and heaps of shredded parmesan make your sauce pop with flavor and brightness.
- → How do I control the spicy kick?
Just use more or less Cajun seasoning and red pepper flakes in your steak and sauce until the heat feels right to you.