Pin it
Turn everyday items into tasty chocolate-peanut butter hearts that mix sweet and salty flavors just right. This no-fuss treat makes a wonderful handmade present or dessert for gatherings.
These goodies take me back to my childhood Valentine's Days, but they're even better when made at home. That crisp chocolate shell breaking open to show the creamy filling inside brings so much happiness.
Pin it
Key Ingredients:
- Smooth peanut butter: Gives that velvety feel
- Confectioners sugar: Makes the right texture
- Premium chocolate chips: Melt better and taste richer
- Shortening: Helps chocolate coat smoothly
- Vanilla extract: Boosts the peanut butter taste
- Salted butter: Cuts through sweetness
Step-By-Step Guide:
- Mix Your Filling
- Whip melted butter with peanut butter
- Mix in sugars bit by bit
- Stir until totally smooth
- Put in a paper-lined dish
- Cut Out Hearts
- Cool mixture until solid
- Press out hearts with cutter
- Stick in freezer for 30 minutes
- Do small batches at a time
- Get Chocolate Ready
- Heat chocolate with shortening
- Mix until shiny
- Watch the warmth level
- Keep everything around you cool
- Coat and Garnish
- Dunk hearts fully
- Let extra chocolate run off
- Top with swirls or candy bits
- Wait until they're firm
When I first made these with my little girl, we found out that putting the hearts in the freezer makes them way easier to dip.
Keeping Things Cool:
Everything needs to stay chilled while you work. A cold counter helps the hearts keep their shape.
Pin it
Smart Storage:
Put them in single rows with paper between layers. Keep in a cool, dry spot for up to two weeks.
Planning Ahead:
Mix up filling and shape hearts early. Save the chocolate dipping for right before you give them away.
Fun Decoration Options:
Mix it up with different toppings and drizzles. Try white chocolate and colorful sprinkles for a party look.
Pin it
Pro Pointers:
- Dip using a fork
- Softly tap to remove extra chocolate
- Don't let filling warm up
- Wait until totally hardened
I've been making these treats for years now, and I've learned that taking your time with temperature really gives you the best-looking results.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's the reason for freezing?
- Hardens the peanut butter to make dipping simpler and keeps chocolate neat.
- → Why is shortening needed?
- Gives the chocolate a silkier finish and stops it from looking cloudy.
- → Can I choose smaller shapes?
- Of course—try a smaller cutter and chill for less time.
- → What’s the best way to store them?
- Put them in the fridge in a sealed container. They'll last about two weeks.
- → How about freezing them?
- Sure thing! Freeze for up to three months, but let them thaw in the fridge.