Pin
Settle in for a cozy evening with this easy single-pot dinner packed with juicy rotisserie chicken, creamy cheddar, tender orzo, and lots of vibrant broccoli. Everything comes together quickly—about half an hour—with hardly any dishes to clean. The velvety, cheesy sauce ties the whole thing together, so every forkful feels both nourishing and totally comforting. Even the picky eaters at your table will be excited for more.
This idea came to life during one of those jam-packed weeks with back-to-back activities and not much time for cooking. My daughter usually tries to avoid broccoli but surprised me by asking for more—greens included—after her first bite. My husband was skeptical about switching from rice to orzo, but after his first helping, he said he liked this even more than our usual chicken and rice bake. Now whenever things get hectic, this is often our go-to dinner after late practices and homework.
Tasty Key Ingredients
Flavor Starters
- Butter & Olive Oil: These two fats join forces—olive oil keeps things from burning while butter brings cozy flavor to everything in the pan
- Sweet Onion: Cooks down so it’s mellow, not harsh, and blends right into the sauce for subtle flavor
- Fresh Garlic: Adds that unbeatable, savory punch you just can’t get from the old jarred stuff
Vegetable Goodness
- Broccoli Florets: These little trees soak up all the cheesy, seasoned flavor. If you keep them roughly the same size, they'll cook evenly
- Italian Seasoning: An all-in-one blend with oregano, thyme, basil, maybe rosemary or marjoram—lets you get herby flavor without opening every spice you own
- Salt & Pepper: Don't be shy with these two, since they help everything else taste better
Creamy Kick
- Orzo: This pasta looks like plump rice grains, cooks fast, and soaks up the sauce for perfect bites throughout
- Chicken Broth: Instead of just water, use broth so every spoonful is savory
- Heavy Cream: A splash of this makes the sauce super silky and rich—suddenly it tastes like comfort food central
Pin
Cheese & Protein
- Rotisserie Chicken: Already-cooked, full of flavor, and saves so much time—plus the hint of roastiness levels up the dish
- Sharp Cheddar: Has enough tang to shine through everything else, and it melts best if you grate it yourself
- Worcestershire Sauce: A dash or two of this adds that savory, hard-to-describe boost that makes everything richer
Effortless Preparation
Get Flavor Going
Toss butter and olive oil into a deep skillet or Dutch oven over medium. When the foamy butter is gone, stir in the onion. Cook 5-ish minutes until it turns soft and a bit brown around the edges for deeper flavor.
Add Those Veggies
Broccoli goes in next. Give it a good stir so it gets all coated in that buttery oil. Cook another few minutes, just until it brightens up but still feels crisp—it’ll keep cooking soon.
Mix in Pasta
Now sprinkle in minced garlic, Italian herbs, and dry orzo. Let them toast briefly (about a minute). This wakes up the herbs, brings out a toasty flavor in pasta, and keeps the garlic from burning or tasting bitter.
Add Liquids
Next, pour in chicken broth, then the cream, and a dash or two of Worcestershire. Give everything a good stir while scraping up those tasty brown bits stuck to the pan.
Simmer Low & Slow
Heat it up to just bubbling, then drop the heat so it gently simmers. Pop the lid on partway and let it cook about 8-10 minutes, giving it a stir here and there. Orzo will drink up the broth while it gets tender, but not mushy.
Check Texture
Most of the liquid should be gone and the orzo should have a little bite left. Too dry before it’s done? Pour in a splash of broth. Looking soupy? Just let it bubble gently with the lid off until it thickens up how you like.
Pin
Add the Chicken
Now stir in your shredded chicken. Let it warm up in the sauce for a couple of minutes—this helps everything blend together and makes sure the chicken gets nice and saucy.
Cheese Time
Pull your pan off the heat and drop in the cheddar (grate it yourself for the best melt). Stir until it melts into a glossy, creamy sauce that covers every bite. No need to crank the heat—the warmth from the pot will do the trick.
Salt & Pepper Check
Taste a spoonful before serving. You’ll probably want to add a good pinch of salt and a few twists of pepper. Pasta and broccoli soaks up salt, so don’t be shy—this is what brings all the flavors together.
The first time I made this, I didn’t season enough at the end—figured there was plenty from the broth and cheese. Everyone ate, but no one raved. I tried the leftovers next day, added some extra salt when reheating, and suddenly it was packed with flavor. Now I always finish with a bold hand on the salt; it unlocks every other ingredient, without making things actually taste salty.
Serving Suggestions
Take things up a notch by serving a chunk of toasted garlic bread next to your orzo. The crispy crust and buttery middle are just right for sopping up any extra cheesy sauce. After a long day, it’s hard to beat the comfort of melty pasta and warm bread on your plate.
Pin
For an easy restaurant touch, scoop this orzo into shallow bowls, drizzle with good olive oil, and sprinkle some chopped fresh herbs on top. It looks fancy, smells great, and a twist of black pepper adds even more appeal and a little kick.
To balance out the richness, whip up a fresh green salad tossed in a zingy vinaigrette. The acidity cuts through the creaminess, adds crunch, and helps the meal feel a bit lighter—even though it’s still totally satisfying.
Fun Variations
For a southwest vibe, swap cheddar for pepper jack and add a can of diced green chiles with the broth. Finish with fresh lime juice and lots of chopped cilantro. Top with avocado slices for extra freshness and color.
Switch to Mediterranean by using feta in place of cheddar, then toss in halved cherry tomatoes, Kalamata olives, and swap out broccoli for a couple handfuls of fresh spinach. Stir spinach in at the very end. The whole dish still ends up creamy, but tastes super bright and light.
If you’re craving seafood, use cooked shrimp or bits of salmon instead of chicken—just stir them in right at the end, since they warm up much faster. Try a splash of white wine with your broth and toss in fresh dill before serving to match those ocean flavors.
Leftover Tips
Leftovers keep best if you move them into a shallow airtight box and pop them in the fridge—good for about three days. Shallow containers chill things faster and you keep the flavors and texture fresher. When you reheat, give things a quick stir to mix it all up again.
Orzo tends to keep soaking up sauce even after it’s cooled. To bring it back to life, warm leftovers slowly with a bit more broth or a mix of broth and cream. Stir gently on the stove or heat up in the microwave, covered with a damp paper towel to stop it drying out.
Day-old leftovers can become a whole new dish: mix in an egg and a little more cheese, press into a buttered pan, and bake until browned for a sliceable, cheesy casserole. Sprinkle on some buttered breadcrumbs before baking if you want a crunchy topping.
Pin
Using the right pot makes a world of difference! The first time, my pan was a little too small—half-cooked orzo and steamed, not sautéed, broccoli was the sad result. Now I always use my big Dutch oven; plenty of room means everything stirs easily and cooks just right. Turns out, picking the proper pot can change everything, especially for all-in-one meals like this.
Recipe Questions & Answers
- → Is there another pasta I can use if I’m out of orzo?
- Sure, grab any small noodles like ditalini or mini shells. Just keep an eye on the cooking time since it could change a bit.
- → I don’t have any rotisserie chicken. Now what?
- No worries! You can use cooked chicken you already have, or quickly sear about a pound of chicken thighs or breast pieces before you start everything else.
- → Can I swap in frozen broccoli for fresh?
- Definitely. Toss frozen broccoli right into the pot as-is. It’s already partially cooked, so shave a minute off the cooking time.
- → What's the best way to store and reheat leftovers?
- Stash leftovers in an airtight container and stick them in the fridge for up to three days. Warm things up slowly, adding a splash of milk or broth to make it creamy again.
- → How can I make this less rich?
- Try using regular milk or half-and-half instead of heavy cream. Use less cheese too—about a cup—to keep things lighter, though it won’t be as thick.